How to Reheat Pizza in Toaster Oven Easily

When it comes to fast food cravings, pizza is still considered one of the top choices. You may have ordered some for yourself or your family and friends. But you may find leftovers on your hands which ultimately go in the fridge. But eventually, it won’t taste the same after getting cold if you get the cravings later.

Don’t worry, with the help of a toaster oven, we can show you some of the best ways to reheat a pizza to make it delicious and fresh, like out of the box. Using a toaster oven to reheat a pizza is one of the best and traditional ways. It’s an ideal option for those who prefer to enjoy the leftovers as a perfect snack.

Do you have to preheat a toaster oven?

Do you have to preheat a toaster oven

You should preheat the toaster oven if you don’t get the best out of your leftover pizza. Preheating the toaster oven might be a time-consuming procedure, although it is worth the wait. 

An ideal temperature of 425 Fahrenheit is preferable, which heats the baking pretty well and cooks the sogginess out of the pizza dough. Preheating allows the temperature inside the oven to reach a certain point where it would thoroughly cook the pizza.

Some ovens such as convection toaster ovens feature a “Reheat” function automatically programmed to operate on the ideal temperature to reheat a pizza. Using a toaster oven instead of a microwave oven to reheat the pizza is preferred as it circulates the warm air properly to melt the cheese and gives a crispy crust.

Best ways to reheat pizza in a Toaster Oven

Toaster ovens are efficient and handy when it comes to reheating leftover pizza. Serve your cravings to get the best out of your leftovers to have an excellent crispy pizza. We will show you some of the best ways to reheat a pizza in a toaster oven.

Step-1 Preheat the toaster oven

First, you need to reheat your toaster oven while the pan sits in the range. The ideal preheat temperature should be set to 425F or 218C for cooking a pizza. The preheat pan cooks the pizza more quickly and thoroughly, leaving no moisture.

Toast the pizza for up to 3-4 minutes, keeping the temperature at 325F (or medium settings) to gradually heat things until the cheese starts melting. Pizzas with thin crust cook faster, so the thickness of the slices matters as well.

Step-2 Spray the pan

The pizza crust may stick in the pan, and it would eventually ruin things up for sure. To prevent that from happening, apply some cooking spray after carefully removing the tray from the preheating process. A bit of butter or any other cooking oil can be used as well if you don’t have cooking spray. 

Step-3 Place pizza slices

Carefully place the pizza slices to cover up the area of the baking pan. Ensure not to stack up the slices as it would stick the pizza slices with melting cheese, causing a mess.

Step-4 Reheating the pizza

After placing the baking tray with pizza slices in the preheated oven, bring down the temperature to the medium settings or 325F, to be precise. Leave the portions for up to 5 to 7 minutes. Once the cheese on the pizza slices begins to melt means the temperature is right. 

Step-5 Ready to serve

Once the pizza slices show the sign of melted cheese after the adjusted time, they are ready to serve. Using a spatula or gloves, carefully take out the tray and let the slices rest for 5 minutes before you can eat them. 

Frequently Asked Questions - FAQs

The reheating of a pizza in a toaster oven may require a preheat procedure to heat the oven and the tray at 425C. Although if you are in a hurry and want to skip the preheating method, you can place the slices in the toaster oven and set the temperature at 325F to begin the reheating process.

The temperature of the oven during the reheating depends on the thickness of the pizza. Also, what kind of output you want from it. If you’re going to enjoy a crispy and crusty pizza, you can raise the temperature.

The preheating procedure of a toaster oven can take 5 to 6 minutes until it’s ready to cook pizza. The temperature should be set at the right level to acquire the efficient use of heating elements.

To cook the frozen pizza, you may have to set your oven at the highest temperature during the preheating procedure. The size of the range varies, and for a small-sized toaster oven, 5 minutes at the highest temperature are sufficient.

After the preheating procedure, you can place your frozen pizza in the toaster oven. Preheat process should warm it up, and then you can set the temperature to medium.

You can leave the pizza for up to 5 to 7 minutes in a medium heating setting, as frozen pizza tends to cook faster. However, it is necessary to preheat the oven before starting the heating process.

Final Thoughts

The toaster oven serves the best of leftover pizza and preheats to a preferable taste. Toaster oven heats the pizza elements and ingredients good as fresh, and they can relieve the cravings whenever you desire. It is an ideal and handy process to enjoy your pizza by making it baked fresh at home following a few simple steps.

Steve here! I like to research and write about best kitchen and home appliances. If you are on the hunt for the best products, quick hacks, and interesting food options, my writing will surely help you out!