Best And Most Useful Toaster Oven Accessories In 2023

If you are looking for a mini bakery in your kitchen, a toaster oven would be the right product to make things happen. A toaster oven is a versatile and easy-to-use product that has become the demand of every kitchen. You can make small-time snacks with these compact appliances. 

Although having a compact size, toaster ovens may not seem like much can be cooked in them. With the help of some useful toaster oven accessories, you can make the best use of your oven’s efficiency. 

These accessories can enhance your oven to bake, grill, and even toast like an all-in-one appliance. A wide range of toaster oven accessories can be found online to choose from. Therefore, we have sorted the best toaster oven accessories and parts which can deliver more in a small package.

Toaster Oven Accessories Buying Guide review

At a Glance – Our Top Picks of Top Rated Toaster Oven Accessories

No products found.


1. Rachael Ray Bakeware Nonstick Cookie Pan Set

No products found.

Item Dimensions: 9-inch x 13-inch, 10-inch x 15-inch,  11-inch x 17-inch | Weight: 6.24 pounds | Max Temperature: 450-500 Fahrenheit | Material: Steel

The pan set features 3 pieces of different sizes so you can use them according to your cooking requirement.

The non-stick features allow easy food release so it assures there is no sticky cookie dough left on the pan. All over non-stick reduces the post-cooking mess cleanup and allows a convenient cooking experience. 

These pans can easily bear a high temperature of up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit. The durability factor keeps the pan in the right shape and bent free keeping it usable for years.

The design is easy to handle with these cooking trays featuring blue drips and extra-wide handles. These pans and dishwashers are safe and easy to clean by hand using dishwashing soap. But before you clean the pan make sure to cool down to a normal temperature.

Comes in 3 different sizes of pan set
The bottom reshapes when it is hot.
High bearable temperature 500 degrees Fahrenheit
The coating may chip after long-term use.
Warp free durable steel built
Overall nonstick
Easy to clean and handle

2. Rachael Ray Cucina Nonstick Bakeware Set

No products found.

Item Dimensions: 10-inch x 15-inch cookie pans, 9-inch round cake pans, 9-inch square cake pan, 9-inch x 13-inch rectangular cake pan | Weight: 13.2 pounds | Max Temperature: 400 Fahrenheit | Material: Steel

This set features 10 pieces of baking equipment covering all your cooking types from muffins to meatloaves.

The complete set is made of heavy-duty stainless steel retaining better heat. The multiple baking pan shapes expand your options and range of making various types of food. The coated layer makes the pans non-stick and easy for you to release the food out of the pan.

The pan set features multiple shapes of cake baking pans in different molds and sizes. You can bake cupcakes, circular, square, and rectangular-shaped cakes in your oven. The baking sheets are best for making sweets and snacks like pizza.

The nonstick coated layer also makes the cleaning process a breeze for dishwashing soap-safe use. Silicon grips are attached to the grips for holding them with ease and properly. It is recommended to use a glove to handle these grips when pulling fresh out of the oven.

4 types of baking sheets for muffins and cakes
May rust if placed in a dishwasher
Versatile and convenient to use
Not scratch resistant
Bear temperature up to 400-degree Fahrenheit
Set includes covering lid for cake sheet
Durable and long-lasting

3. Unicook Heavy Duty Cordierite Pizza Stone

No products found.

Item Dimensions: 14.96 x 11.81 x 0.63 inches | Weight: 6.5 pounds | Max Temperature: 1450 Fahrenheit Material: Natural Cordierite | Shape: Rectangular

This pizza stone is ideal for both oven and grill use.

Making pizza on a natural Cordierite gives you some benefits including odorless results and better heat distributions to the cooking materials. As compared to the metal pans, it saves you from the trouble of rust and wraps as well. 

Whenever you feel the cravings for pizza, just preheat the pizza stone in the oven and place your decorated pizza in for cooking. The porous structure of the pizza stone would naturally absorb any moisture giving you crispy and perfectly cooked results.

This pizza stone can handle high temperatures of up to 1,450°F. The durable structure makes it resistant to high temperatures. Although do handle the pizza stone with care. Make sure not to clean it with washing detergent as it may soak a lot of water. Always use a dry cloth or scraper to remove the excess food attached to the surface.

Natural odorless Cordierite
The dough may stick to the porous surface
Excellent for baking bread and cookies
Hard to clean
Perfect size for RV ovens
Gives crispy results
Excellent heat retention

4. CastElegance Durable & Safe Thermarite Pizza Stone

No products found.

Item Dimensions: 14 x 14 x 0.63 inches | Weight: 5.66 pounds | Max Temperature: 2000 Fahrenheit Material: Circular | Shape: Thermarite Cordierite

The cordierite material factor gives you odorless and evenly heated results.

This pizza stone can withstand an extreme temperature of 2000 degrees Fahrenheit. The extra durable formulation of cordierite, Thermarite, gives it extra strength and sturdiness. The porous structure on the pizza stone makes it taste much better than the steel or aluminum quality baking pans. Moreover, it absorbs any moisture from the pizza dough giving it a crispy gooey structure.

The cleaning procedure can be carried out with the scraper included in the packaging of the product. Do not use soap or detergent to clean the pizza stone as it may ruin its weight and structure. Avoid using oils to moisturize for sticking preventions as it may leave the stone with permanent marks.

Lightweight and sturdy
Limited for pizza baking
Perfect for pizza baking
Requires more preheat
Withstand 2000 Fahrenheit
Odorless results
Includes cleaning scraper

5. AmazonBasics Silicone, Non-Stick, Food Safe Baking Mat

No products found.

Item Dimensions: 11.6×16.5 inches | Weight: 8.5 Ounces | Max Temperature: 480 Fahrenheit Material: Silicone | Shape: Rectangular

The Amazon basic products provide you with the average daily use items which can make a huge difference. The set of two non-stick baking mats are perfect for your half-sheet-sized pans.

These baking mats prevent the food from sticking in the metallic or aluminum pan. The silicone helps to distribute heat evenly to the food and it can easily bear heat up to 480-degree Fahrenheit. The material of these mats makes them reusable in the long term. Using baking mats is a much better and smarter option than placing oil to prevent stickiness.

Better price
Cannot withstand higher temperature
Great for cookies and cakes
Not easy to clean
Better heat distribution
Better replacement for parchment paper

6. Silicone Baking Mats – Non-Stick Sheet Mat

No products found.

Item Dimensions: 16.5 x 0.75 x 11.63 inches | Weight: 8 Ounces | Max Temperature: 400 Fahrenheit Material: Rectangular | Shape: Silicone

These products are high in demand by professional chefs and bakers in the market.

The silicon layer mats have a food-grade quality that evenly distributes heat to your cookies and cakes. The thick layer of these mats offers non-stick services for longer-term with the same results. The fiberglass mesh shape allows it to retain shape and offer versatility. 

The silicon layer makes it easy to clean with just a wipe. These silicon mats are perfect for half-sized pans and can withstand up to 450 Fahrenheit temperature.

Easy to clean
May leave a chemical taste in food
Even heat distribution
Cannot withstand higher temperature
Lasts up to 3000 bakes
Thicker in size than usual non stick sheets

7. HOMWE Extra Long Professional Silicone Oven Mitt

No products found.

Item Dimensions: 15.31 x 9.65 x 1.61 inches | Weight: 14.4 Ounces | Max Temperature: 450 Fahrenheit Material: Silicone| Size: 14.7 inches | Fill Material: Polyester

The material of the gloves is made of high-grade silicone which makes them flexible and durable. These gloves can withstand high temperatures and steam effects of up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit. The textured structure designed on the gloves offers a strong grip so you don’t drop anything while cooking. The silicone material factor makes these gloves easy to clean with water. 

These gloves are long enough to carry large handles and grips of heated pans and fit perfectly in your hands. You can easily hang them in your kitchen and they suit the aesthetic of your cooking place.

Non-slip grip
Inner layering may fall apart
Heat and Steam resistant up to 450 Fahrenheit
Not fit for small hands
Easy to clean
Lightweight and durable

8. HOMWE Silicone Oven Mitts and Potholders

No products found.

Item Dimensions: 13.58 x 8.23 x 2.13 inches | Weight: 15.5 Ounces | Max Temperature: 450 Fahrenheit Material: Silicone | Trivett’s dimension: 7×7 inches | Fill Material: Polyester

The set of these silicone kitchen sets includes 2 silicon gloves and 2 trivet mats.

The gloves and mats have a unique texture grip to hold better the hot objects and pans in your kitchen. The mats hold your heated bowls and pans on the kitchen countertop avoiding them from slipping away. The gloves are best for holding pans and pots which keeps you safe from any burns.

You can use the trivet mats to hold the pan for an instant if you don’t feel like using the gloves. The gloves and trivet mats, both are durable and heat resistant made from the same top-quality silicon material. The water-resistant factor makes them easy to clean. These gloves offer better resistance that you can even dip your hand in boiling water while cooking.

Heat and Steam resistant
Quality concern with inner layers
Cannot bear the heat for longer
Machine Washable
Best for both indoor and outdoor use
Trivets mats included in the set


While purchasing these products or accessories make sure the following factors:

  • These products are suitable for kitchen appliances such as Toaster ovens.
  • These accessories are according to your cooking requirements.
  • Make sure to follow the precautions and heat limits while using these accessories.
  • Make sure the size of pan sheets is suitable with your toaster oven.
  • Make sure to check the cleaning guidance on specific products like pizza stones.

Related: Best Microwave Toaster Oven Combo

Frequently Asked Questions – FAQs

Can you use silicone baking dishes in a toaster oven?

The silicon mats can be used in the toaster oven for baking purposes. You can place these silicon mats on baking sheets for non-stick cooking.

Why can’t you use parchment paper in a toaster oven?

Parchment paper cannot withstand higher temperatures and may catch fire in the oven. A better alternative is a silicone baking mat which serves the purpose in a better way without any oil or cooking spray use.

Can you bake a cake in a toaster oven?

You can bake small cakes and cupcakes in a toaster oven with the help of molded steel pans.


The purpose behind using these kitchen accessories is to expand the cooking experience with the assistance of safety. Using accessories such as baking pans expands your options of recipes and improvises the use of your toaster oven. Do make sure that you choose the best toaster oven accessories that are suitable for your kitchen appliances.

Steve here! I like to research and write about best kitchen and home appliances. If you are on the hunt for the best products, quick hacks, and interesting food options, my writing will surely help you out!